The Quest for Canada

Battle of Quebec

Power Point Presentation | Detailed Lesson Plan

 

Benedict Arnold is most well-known for his betrayal of American forces to the British during the Revolutionary War. Before that, however, he also tried to lead American forces in a Canadian invasion that ultimately ended in disaster. Arnold asked Georgre Washington for troops to invade Canada in 1775. At the time, the British had control of the country, and its northern position meant that the British could use it to attack the colonies to the south. Arnold also hoped that French Canadians living in the region would fight for independence along with the Americans. Canada was also not well guarded; the British only had 775 troops in the entire country, with less than 300 in Quebec. Washington approved the mission, sending some troops to Montreal and 1050 men, along with Arnold, through Maine to the fortified city of Quebec. Patriot forces under Richard Montgomery had successfully taken Montreal; if Arnold's army could take Quebec, Canada would be in American hands.

 

Benedict Arnold in 1776
Benedict Arnold in 1776

Major Logistical Problems

Arnold's ill-fated mission encountered problems from the very beginning. The group left later than expected, in September, due to issues with paying the men. Next, Arnold's map was inaccurate, and the path to the destination took well longer than expected. To make things worse, the army's shipbuilder was a British sympathizer who sabotaged the vessels, and much of their supplies ended up sinking to the bottom of a freezing cold river. To make matters worse, a hurricane destroyed many of the remaining materials, causing some soldiers to desert. Others were deathly ill from dysentery. By the time Arnold reached Canada in November, he had a mere 675 starving soldiers and hardly any supplies. However, British commander Sir Guy Carleton had already gotten wind of the attack, and British reinforcements were stationed in Quebec City. Arnold waited for more troops to arrive and attacked on New Year's Eve before attempting a siege of the city.

Arnold's Growing Disenchantment

Even more of Arnold's troops perished in the battle - of the 300 that survived to the fight, less than 100 escaped. Arnold was injured during the fight by a gunshot, and had to be dragged off the field with a shattered leg. Nevertheless, he kept fighting, using a single cannon to make it seem as though the Americans had a larger military force than they did. In the spring, reinforcements from New England arrived, allowing the Americans to stage a partial blockade of the city for several months. In May 1776, a British fleet arrived in the region, forcing the colonists to abandon their failed quest to conquer Canada. Afterwards, Arnold continued to be passed over for  promotion in the Continental Army in favor of other officers. That, combined with his doomed quest to take Canada, may have fueled the fire for his later betrayal of the revolution.

 

Before Benedict Arnold became known for betraying America, he tried to lead a mission to take over Canada in 1775. At the time, Canada was controlled by the British, and Arnold believed that taking it would prevent British attacks from the north. He also hoped the French Canadians would join the fight for independence. Washington approved the plan and sent Arnold and 1,050 men through Maine to capture Quebec. Meanwhile, another force had already taken Montreal. If Arnold could take Quebec, Canada might fall into American hands.

Major Logistical Problems

From the start, Arnold’s journey was full of problems. The group left late due to payment issues. Arnold’s map was wrong, and the trip took much longer than expected. A British supporter who built their boats sabotaged them, and many supplies sank in a cold river. A hurricane destroyed more materials, some soldiers deserted, and many became sick with dysentery. By November, Arnold had only 675 starving men left. Meanwhile, British troops in Quebec were ready. Arnold waited for backup, then attacked on New Year’s Eve.

Arnold's Growing Disenchantment

The attack on Quebec failed. Of the 300 soldiers who joined the fight, fewer than 100 made it out. Arnold was shot and had to be carried off with a broken leg. Still, he tried to keep up the fight using a single cannon to trick the British into thinking the American force was larger. In spring, more troops arrived and helped surround the city for a while. But in May 1776, British ships came, and the Americans had to retreat. After the failed mission, Arnold was again passed over for promotion. This, along with the defeat in Canada, may have led to his later betrayal.